07/17/2026
Friday Fails
I wanted to share a photo that a fellow landscape lighting provider sent me, as it is another example of what is being done within our scope of work. We've all been exposed to this...the "electrician" performing landscape lighting work. These are the wrong people to employ for thoughtful design.
I'm not saying that this lighting layout is bad, but there are several things wrong with it. Here's what is wrong:
1) An old-school approach using whatever is shown in a catalog or whatever is on the shelf at the distributor. They use flood lights, up lights, and even pathlights/bollards for everything.
2) Over-sized fixtures in small spaces. This is what you see on most all commercial projects...think, Las Vegas or the shopping mall.
3) Overkill approach to illumination. Look at the flood lights within the "red" circles. One is aimed at the low wall, and the other is aimed at some small starter shrubs. Both of these are going to "flood" light out across the whole space, over the wall/shrubs, and beyond into the sky. In other words, it's all wasted illumination.
4) Lack of care for energy efficiency. Who knows what light sources they are using inside, but I can guarantee it's not as efficient as what a 12-v. a landscape lighting system could provide.
5) Rigidly installed and located light fixture positions. Although I am a fan of installing conduit, the systems must be flexible enough to relocate fixtures easily. Being that this lighting is 120-v. it is buried atleast 12" or more in the ground. This will make relocating fixtures more of a nightmare as these trees grow (see "yellow" circles for those up lights).
6) Up light positioning ("yellow" circles). What is the 'design intent' here? Each of the three trees has the same placement of up lights, so from one street (to the right or left) they will look stronger (intensity on the trunking) versus the streets at 90-degrees in either direction...less intense. This could have been designed to create more impact or depth (although limited) by positioning them differently.
It is highly likely that an engineer-type person, who has little to no experience in landscape lighting, has specified this job. However, because their company was awarded the line-voltage work on the job, they were awarded this work too.
When will our cities, government agencies, developers, etc. begin to realize what they are doing? They are NOT lighting designers, nor do they have the experience to know better.