25/01/2023
A really good read!
I had a few people reach out to me yesterday about an email from a well known baby company offering some… interesting advice in regard to night feeds. This email, aimed at babies aged 11 months old, tells parents that:
“If your little one is regularly downing more than about a pint of milk a day there’s a danger they’ll fill up on milk and then be a light or picky eater during the day. Not only is this frustrating for you, it can also have the knock-on effect that hunger will strike again in the dead of night, causing your little monster to get you out of bed for a milk top up feed."
The article goes on to tell us to simply “cut out the night time feed or replace it with water.” In order to “Reset the pattern of three good solid meals, daytime milk and no night time waking.”
The parents who reached out to me were wondering if the article is accurate or not. So I thought we could look at a really useful study:
In 2015, Professor Amy Brown did a study where she found almost 80% of babies aged between 6 and 12 months of age were waking AT LEAST once most nights. A little over 60% of these babies were having milk feeds when waking. This was the same regardless of whether the baby was breastfed or formula fed.
While Prof Brown DID find that babies were less likely to feed at night if they ate more solids in the day, they were NOT less likely to wake up. Let me say that again:
MOST babies wake up at night REGARDLESS of how they are fed and giving them MORE solid food in the day is NOT proven to reduce night time wake ups.
Denying little ones milk when they wake up won’t make them sleep better. It MIGHT make them grumpy, keep you awake for longer, and if you’re breastfeeding, it could cause blocked ducts, mastitis or even reduced milk supply.
The NHS is deliberately vague about night-time feeding and sleeping. Across their various messaging you’ll notice statements such as “Some babies will be sleeping through the night at this age.” Or “Your baby will wake to feed for at least the first several months and even longer.” There is NO formal guidance in the UK that says babies SHOULD be sleeping through the night by a certain point.
Remember that until around 12 months of age the main source of nutrition for babies is MILK. Yes, they need solids – but it is NOT advised to deliberately cut out night time feeds in favour of solid food.
For EVIDENCE-BASED and holistic sleep supporting, check out my downloadable, pre-recorded Holistic Sleep 101 Workshop. It is suitable for babies from birth to school age, and is suitable regardless of how your baby gets milk. You can access this via my website - link in the comments!
(Source: Amy Brown Infant Sleep and Night Feeding Patterns During Later Infancy: Association with Breastfeeding Frequency, Daytime Complementary Food Intake, and Infant Weight. Breastfeeding Medicine volume 10, 2015)