Empty Nose Syndrome - Surgery-Caused Autonomic And Respiratory Dysfunction

  • Hem
  • Sverige
  • Stockholm
  • Empty Nose Syndrome - Surgery-Caused Autonomic And Respiratory Dysfunction

Empty Nose Syndrome - Surgery-Caused Autonomic And Respiratory Dysfunction I am a whistleblower who is revealing ongoing mistreatment of patients at ENT clinics world wide

Summary of the StudyCarnevale et al. (2011) – Effectiveness of Adaptive Servo-Ventilation in the Treatment of Hypocapnic...
30/05/2026

Summary of the Study

Carnevale et al. (2011) – Effectiveness of Adaptive Servo-Ventilation in the Treatment of Hypocapnic Central Sleep Apnea of Various Etiologies

This study evaluated the long-term effectiveness of Adaptive Servo-Ventilation (ASV) in 74 patients with hypocapnic central sleep apnea (CSA), including patients with heart failure, neurological disorders, and idiopathic CSA. The average follow-up period was approximately 36 months.

The researchers found that ASV significantly improved sleep-disordered breathing:

* The apnea-hypopnea index (AHI) decreased from 47.4 to 6.9 events per hour.
* Nighttime oxygen saturation improved.
* Daytime sleepiness, measured by the Epworth Sleepiness Scale, was significantly reduced in patients who used ASV regularly.
* Patients with heart failure who were compliant with treatment also showed improvement in functional status (NYHA class).
* Importantly, ASV significantly reduced chronic hyperventilation, as demonstrated by blood gas measurements.

Average treatment adherence was good, with patients using ASV for approximately 5–6 hours per night.

Conclusion

The authors concluded that ASV is generally well tolerated and effective for most patients with hypocapnic central sleep apnea and chronic hyperventilation. The therapy improved breathing stability during sleep, reduced apnea events, improved oxygenation and daytime symptoms, and helped reduce chronic over-ventilation.

Our findings suggest that ASV is well tolerated and effective for most patients with hypocapnic central sleep apnea and chronic hyperventilation.

19/05/2026

From the study:

Overall, these findings suggest that ENS symptom manifestation and ANS dysfunction may be closely interconnected. However, because causality cannot be established within the scope of this study, it remains possible that chronic nasal symptoms and mucosal alterations associated with ENS may secondarily induce ANS dysfunction.

Study summary

Title: Assessment of Autonomic Dysfunction in Patients With Empty Nose Syndrome Using the Composite Autonomic Symptom Scale-31
Journal: Journal of Rhinology (J Rhinol), 2025;32(3):162–168
DOI: 10.18787/jr.2025.00043

Authors: Sung Seok Ryu, MD; Do Yeon Kim, MD; Yong Ju Jang, MD, PhD
Institution: Department of Otorhinolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, Asan Medical Center, University of Ulsan College of Medicine, Seoul, South Korea

Objective

The study investigated whether patients with Empty Nose Syndrome (ENS) show evidence of autonomic nervous system (ANS) dysfunction, using the validated questionnaire COMPASS-31, compared with asymptomatic controls.

Methods
26 ENS patients and 43 control participants were included.
ENS diagnosis was based on:
history of turbinate surgery
characteristic symptoms
endoscopic/CT findings
ENS6Q questionnaire (and in some cases cotton test confirmation)
ENS patients completed both COMPASS-31 (autonomic symptoms) and ENS6Q (nasal symptoms).
Controls completed COMPASS-31 only.
Key results
ENS patients had significantly higher total COMPASS-31 scores than controls, indicating a greater burden of autonomic symptoms.
No strong overall correlation was found between total ENS symptom severity (ENS6Q) and COMPASS-31 scores.
However, nasal crusting severity showed a significant positive correlation with COMPASS-31 scores.
Main findings
ENS is associated with increased symptoms consistent with autonomic dysfunction, including dryness, sweating abnormalities, and urinary symptoms.
Most individual autonomic domains were not significantly different between groups.
The link between ENS and autonomic dysfunction appears partial and symptom-specific rather than uniform across all systems.
Conclusion

The study suggests that ENS is associated with increased autonomic symptom burden and possible autonomic nervous system involvement, particularly related to nasal mucosal function and crusting. However, causality cannot be established.

Simple interpretation

Patients with ENS show more signs consistent with autonomic dysregulation compared to controls, but the study does not prove that ENS directly causes autonomic dysfunction—only that they are associated.

Empty Nose Syndrome – A Devastating Condition Denied by a System That Cannot Admit HarmEmpty nose syndrome, a condition ...
01/05/2026

Empty Nose Syndrome – A Devastating Condition Denied by a System That Cannot Admit Harm

Empty nose syndrome, a condition so devastating, so destabilizing that many patients describe it as the destruction of their ability to exist inside their own body. And yet, despite overwhelming testimony from thousands of sufferers, ENS remains one of the most denied and dismissed conditions in modern medicine.

Why? Why do so many doctors reject a condition that steals sleep, destroys breathing, dysregulates the nervous system and pushes some patients into unbearable suffering? Why are patients who underwent surgeries marketed as safe, waking up to a nightmare that the medical system refuses to acknowledge? The truth is uncomfortable.

The truth is deeply human, and the truth is this: empty nose syndrome is not ignored by accident. It is ignored because accepting it would force a confrontation with surgical harm on a scale the ENT profession is not psychologically, economically, or institutionally prepared to face. Admitting ENS means acknowledging that surgeons have removed vital anatomical structures without fully understanding their functions.

It means acknowledging that training was incomplete, that physiology, neurobiology, mechanoreception, CO2 regulation, mucosal integrity and nasal airflow resistance were never taught in depth. It means admitting that a procedure sold as harmless has caused lifelong disability, panic, hypoventilation, hyperventilation cycles, chronic sympathetic overdrive, broken sleep mechanisms, and in the worst cases — su***de.

When professionals profit from a procedure, when their reputation and identity are built on it, when hospitals generate income from it, and when complication rates determine liability, denial becomes the most convenient defense mechanism. Human psychology chooses self-protection over empathy. It is always easier to say the patient is anxious than to admit we permanently damaged their breathing system.

Across ENS communities, thousands of people describe losing the ability to sleep, the ability to regulate breathing, the ability to stay calm, the ability to function, and tragically some lose the ability to continue living. In just two ENS support groups, with around 5,000 to 7,000 combined members, 8 individuals died by su***de in 2024.

Their deaths are documented by friends, family, and fellow sufferers. The stories, memorials and personal accounts are publicly available. This record documents the su***des, the patients’ stories, and the reality that the medical system refuses to acknowledge.

It shows the human cost of denial, the suffering of those whose lives were destroyed after trusting a procedure that promised relief. And yet the medical system continues to say, “ENS does not exist”, or “the symptoms are psychological”. This is not science. This is self-preservation. It is cognitive dissonance in its purest form: “I did this surgery…”

But the human consequences are very real. ENS patients experience a minute ventilation collapse, too little CO2, alkalosis, chronic air hunger, sympathetic overload. They cannot sleep because the neural receptors that guide the breathing-sleep interface are gone or silenced.

Their nose becomes a tunnel of dry burning air that triggers constant stress signals. These reactions are not psychological. They are physiological, mechanical, and neurological. Why doesn’t the system intervene?

Because to intervene, regulators and medical authorities would have to admit that thousands of unnecessary surgeries were performed without informed consent. Without proper warnings and without full understanding, it would reveal that a surgical field carried on with inadequate training for decades.

It would expose liability. It would force a rewrite of textbooks, guidelines, and reimbursement structures. It would open the door to lawsuits globally. So they protect the system instead of the patient.

Many doctors simply cannot empathize with ENS because they cannot imagine a nose could have such catastrophic effects. They have never experienced loss of airflow sensation, loss of nasal airflow resistance, the suffocation paradox of an “open nose” that feels closed, the constant respiratory instability, or the way chronic hyperventilation gradually destroys the mind.

Without this lived experience and without proper education, they default to minimizing the patient’s suffering. Not out of cruelty, but out of narrowness — and narrowness becomes cruelty when it prevents recognition of harm.

ENS remains unacknowledged because it asks too much of the people responsible. It demands humility. It demands admitting mistakes. It demands confronting the limitations of surgical training and the dangers of unnecessary turbinate reductions, performed for profit, convenience, or simple lack of understanding.

So instead, patients are left to navigate a nightmare alone, one that has already cost lives.

And unless regulators, researchers, and ENT leadership finally step forward, unless they listen to the testimonies, unless they read the memorials, unless they choose courage over comfort, history will record that an entire medical field looked away while patients suffered in silence.

ENS is not rare — it is simply unrecognized — and the suffering is not psychological, it is engineered.

To anyone living with ENS: you are not imagining your symptoms, you are not anxious, you are experiencing a real condition that modern medicine is decades behind in understanding.

You deserve validation, you deserve compassion, you deserve treatment, and you deserve a medical system that has the courage to face the consequences of its own actions.

The silence will not last forever. The more voices speak out, the harder it becomes for the system to hide. And the truth — your truth — will eventually be impossible to ignore.

Asked Ai about two surgeons in Turkey ⸻🧑‍⚕️ Prof. Dr. Mustafa Deniz YılmazProf. Dr. Mustafa Deniz Yılmaz - KBB ve Baş Bo...
19/02/2026

Asked Ai about two surgeons in Turkey



🧑‍⚕️ Prof. Dr. Mustafa Deniz Yılmaz

Prof. Dr. Mustafa Deniz Yılmaz - KBB ve Baş Boyun Cerrahisi Kliniği
Web
Address: BJK Store Üstü, Pınarbaşı Mahallesi, Atatürk. Bulvarı 705. Sokak, Gül Sitesi A Blok Kat:1 Daire:1, 07070 Konyaaltı, Türkiye
Phone: +905537053650

Professional Background & Specialties
• Experienced Ear, Nose & Throat (ENT) specialist and head & neck surgeon based in Antalya, Turkey. 
• His clinic offers a wide range of services including rhinoplasty (nose surgery), revision rhinoplasty, vertigo/balance testing and treatment, tinnitus evaluation, ear surgery, and pediatric ENT care. 
• The clinic specifically lists Empty Nose Syndrome (ENS) diagnosis and management as one of the conditions addressed. 
• His website shows a professional team including audiologists and support staff. 

Patient Ratings & Reviews
• Google reviews show an overall 4.8–4.9/5 rating based on many patient comments. 
• Reviews contain numerous testimonials from patients who had:
• Successful breathing and aesthetic improvements after nose surgery, with positive remarks about care and recovery. 
• Patients with Empty Nose Syndrome who reported improvement after surgical treatment, including cartilage reconstruction. 
• Effective management of other ENT conditions such as tonsillectomy, Meniere’s disease, vasomotor rhinitis, hearing loss, vertigo, sinus issues, and more. 
• Several reviewers highlight good communication, attentive follow-up, and strong post-surgery support. 
• Most patient comments are highly positive, with only very few neutral/negative remarks visible in the aggregated public reviews. 

Online Presence
• The clinic’s website includes detailed service descriptions and patient testimonials. 
• Many reviews are from people treated as recently as 2024–2025, showing ongoing active practice and updated feedback. 



🧑‍⚕️ Dr. Murat Enoz

Doç.Dr. Murat Enöz, ENT Doctor, Burun Estetiği, Tip Plasty, Rhinoplasty, Nose Job Surgery, Istanbul
Web
Address: İncirli Cad. Dilek Pastanesi Üstü, Kat:4, No:41, Zuhuratbaba Mahallesi, 34147 Bakırköy/İstanbul, Türkiye
Phone: +902125610052

Professional Background & Specialties
• Dr. Murat Enoz is an ENT specialist and surgeon in Istanbul with a private practice focusing largely on nasal function and aesthetics. 
• Services include rhinoplasty (cosmetic and functional), tip plasty, septoplasty, and related nose surgeries performed in his private office. 
• He appears to treat both local and international patients, with office location near the airport for easier access. 

Awards & Notable Mentions
• Dr. Enoz received a 2024 WhatClinic Patient Service Award, which is an industry recognition based on verified patient satisfaction surveys. 

Patient Ratings & Reviews
• According to external listings, Google reviews for his practice are very strong (reported around 5.0/5 with hundreds of reviews). 
• Review excerpts include praise for:
• Natural and satisfactory rhinoplasty results. 
• Good communication from the doctor before, during, and after treatment, including follow-ups for questions. 
• Experienced handling of expectations and outcomes. 
• Some patients note differences in language availability (doctor was reported to speak good English, but nursing staff may not). 

Online Presence
• His official website shows services and general profile (historically since at least 2018). 
• His clinic appears in third-party healthcare listings with summaries of services and some patient stories. 



🔎 Summary Comparison

Feature Prof. Dr. Mustafa Deniz Yılmaz Dr. Murat Enoz
Primary Location Antalya Istanbul
Overall Google Rating (public) ~4.8–4.9 / 5  ~5.0 / 5 
Specializations ENT, rhinoplasty, vertigo, hearing, ENS, pediatric ENT  ENT, cosmetic and functional rhinoplasty 
Patient Testimonials Many covering breathing, sinus, vertigo, tinnitus, ENS corrections  Many praising rhinoplasty results and patient satisfaction 
Awards / Recognition — WhatClinic Patient Service Award 2024 
International Patient Traffic Yes (multiple reviews from abroad)  Yes (noted by reviewers, award, and listings) 



📌 Notes & Important Context
• Reviews vary in detail and origin: Some are from local patients, others are international. Online reviews can reflect personal experiences but may not fully represent outcomes.
• ENS-specific outcomes: Several reviewers for Dr. Yılmaz mention successful Empty Nose Syndrome management after multiple failed prior treatments. 
• Language aspects: For Dr. Enoz, there are specific mentions that the doctor speaks English well, though support staff may not. 



🔗 Sources (Links for Verification)

Prof. Dr. Mustafa Deniz Yılmaz
• Clinic website: https://www.denizyilmaz.com.tr/
• Patient reviews and comments: https://denizyilmaz.com.tr/en/comments/
• Clinic services and patient testimonials: https://denizyilmaz.com.tr/en/
• ENS info on website: https://denizyilmaz.com.tr/en/empty-nose-syndrome-ens/
• Vertigo center page: https://vertigocenter.org/comments/

Dr. Murat Enoz
• Google business info: (see above entity)
• WhatClinic award article: https://www.ent-istanbul.com/2025/04/r-murat-enoz-ent-specialist-selected-as-whatclinic-patient-service-award-2024.html
• HealMinded clinic summary with reviews: https://healminded.co.uk/facilities/docdr-murat-enoz-ent-doctor-burun-estetigi-tip-plasty-rhinoplasty-nose-job-surgery-istanbul
• Background info from his site: https://www.muratenoz.com/2018/02/dr-murat-enoz-detaylar.html

Murat Enöz hangi hastanede? - Murat Enöz instagram - Murat Enöz kimdir? - Murat Enöz muayene ücreti - Murat Enöz yorumlar - Dr.Murat Enöz hakkında - ENT Doctor in Istanbul

Ens Researchers Need Your Help!Like you all know ENS is a devastating but largely unrecognized condition. The Modena Sci...
13/12/2025

Ens Researchers Need Your Help!

Like you all know ENS is a devastating but largely unrecognized condition. The Modena Science Project is researching ENS to find better treatments — but they can’t do it without your voice.

Listen to this podcast and share it to help:
• Raise awareness
• Support research
• Give patients a chance for recognition and care

Every share matters. Let’s make ENS visible.

https://open.spotify.com/episode/56qIL4jbAvT7bvC2rSicdv?si=e5adUNw2TMWOybj9pFbZdQ

EMPTY NOSE SYNDROME - Turbinate Reduction: New Era "Lobotomy" · Episode

Adress

Stockholm

Webbplats

https://www.facebook.com/groups/798149274095716/, https://open.spotify.com/show/1gKZlA

Aviseringar

Var den första att veta och låt oss skicka ett mail när Empty Nose Syndrome - Surgery-Caused Autonomic And Respiratory Dysfunction postar nyheter och kampanjer. Din e-postadress kommer inte att användas för något annat ändamål, och du kan när som helst avbryta prenumerationen.

Dela