09/02/2026
🎃 Halloween is supposed to be scary because of ghosts, skeletons, and children appearing at your door dressed as inflatable dinosaurs. It is not supposed to be scary because the ingredient label forgot to mention a major allergen.
Crystal Temptations has recalled Chocolatey Eyeballs because the candy contains whey, which comes from milk, but milk was not declared on the label. For families managing milk allergies, that is a much bigger fright than anything hiding in a haunted house.
The recalled candy was sold through Marshalls, TJ Maxx, HomeGoods, and Sierra Trading Post in multiple states and includes several package sizes. If you have this candy at home, especially if you already started assembling Halloween treats, check the package before anyone eats it.
The company advises consumers to destroy the affected product and contact Crystal Temptations for a refund. No illnesses had been reported as of August 31, 2026.
And this is exactly why I keep talking about reading labels, checking recalls, and looking at ingredients every single time, even when you have purchased the same type of product before.
👁️ The eyeballs were supposed to be creepy.
🥛 The undeclared milk was not.
Please share this with parents, grandparents, teachers, caregivers, and anyone already stockpiling Halloween candy like October is a competitive sport.
Restoration Wellness of Idaho LLC
Public Health Education