08/11/2026
Unpopular opinion: I think most “shoulder relief” girths create more discomfort than relief.
There. I said it. 😂 Nobody come at me with a pitchfork yet.
I’m not saying every shoulder relief girth is bad tack, or that every horse wearing one is uncomfortable.
I’m saying that as someone who spends a whole lot of time paying attention to how horses actually use their bodies, and has my hands on a lot of horses as we make changes to improve their bodies through bodywork, tack adjustments etc. I think we sometimes get a little too attached to the idea that a certain girth automatically is better.
Unfortunately, I find it a bit related to the French phrase il faut souffrir pour être belle "One must suffer to be beautiful".
Regardless of the popularity, we must keep in mine that we should not accept discomfort in the name of fashion, and we must look at the actual results as they pertain to the whole body.
Because the horse’s body doesn’t exist in isolated pieces. It doesnt exist in its wellness based on how much money you spent, or if its the hottest thing on the market.
The sternum, pectorals, thoracic sling, ribs, scapula, shoulder, girth area, and abdominal structures are all part of a connected system. Change where and how pressure is distributed in one area, and you change what other tissues have to do.
And sometimes, when I put my hands on a horse who is routinely wearing one of these girths, I find the story in the muscles. And I find myself thinking:
* Why are we assuming this horse is more comfortable just because the girth isn't sitting where we traditionally expect it to?
* Why are we not using a simple design? With less rigidity?
* Why are we holding on to this "technology" here when its not working for this particular animal?
Because the horse doesn't care what the marketing says, he only cares whether he can breathe, move, stabilize, bend, reach, and use his body without unnecessary efforts, pressures, and restrictions.
I think we should be looking at the individual horse rather than assuming a particular piece of tack is inherently more comfortable because of the way it was designed.
Sometimes the answer really is, better tack, better body support on a maintenance schedule.
If you brought a pitchfork, and youre not using it on me yet, just feel free to clean the barn.